美华文学主页
在线情况
楼主
  • 头像
  • 级别
    • 职务总版主
    • 财富7
    • 积分689005
    • 经验148181
    • 文章9466
    • 注册2005-07-12
    [评论][原创]《里见传说-英文版》意見收集
    《里见传说-英文版》的读者们,

    第一部 雷之卷 已贴上了, 如有任何意见, 请在此发言, 谢谢.


    美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
    在线情况
    2
    • 头像
    • 级别
      • 职务总版主
      • 财富7
      • 积分689005
      • 经验148181
      • 文章9466
      • 注册2005-07-12
      第二部 缎和铁之卷 (英文版)已贴上了, 请指教
      美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
      在线情况
      3
      • 头像
      • 级别
        • 积分3960
        • 经验2571
        • 文章14
        • 注册2006-08-10

        Just finished the first chapter, the opening is good.
        But, too many Japanese that I don't understand.


        [img]../images/fileType/gif.gif[/img]此主题相关图片
        [imga]../images/upload/2006/12/03/055615.gif[/imga]


        請大家多多指教唷!
        在线情况
        4
        • 头像
        • 级别
          • 职务总版主
          • 财富7
          • 积分689005
          • 经验148181
          • 文章9466
          • 注册2005-07-12
          You can ask here or pm me...
          美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
          在线情况
          5
          • 头像
          • 级别
            • 积分3960
            • 经验2571
            • 文章14
            • 注册2006-08-10
            The more XXX you got, the more books you can sell.


            [img]../images/fileType/gif.gif[/img]此主题相关图片
            [imga]../images/upload/2006/12/06/214648.gif[/imga]
            請大家多多指教唷!
            在线情况
            6
            • 头像
            • 级别
              • 积分3960
              • 经验2571
              • 文章14
              • 注册2006-08-10
              How come the English version is different from Chinese version? I mean the description of the death of Karoio.  

              I would like to know some more abt the appearance of Hitomi and Aniue.

              my 2 cents

              [img]../images/fileType/gif.gif[/img]此主题相关图片
              [imga]../images/upload/2006/12/07/021226.gif[/imga]
              請大家多多指教唷!
              在线情况
              7
              • 头像
              • 级别
                • 职务总版主
                • 财富7
                • 积分689005
                • 经验148181
                • 文章9466
                • 注册2005-07-12
                Basically they are the same. I have abridged some parts to make it less offensive to some in the Chinese version.  
                Who is Karoio?  
                The English version was basically an unedited and un-proof read draft and contains a lot of mistakes, including some names who have been changed but I forget to follow up with subsequent chapters.

                As for Hitomi, sorry, that is all left to your imagination.  She is very pretty of course, being the Yamabuki of Satomi.  
                Aniue is not a person, it is a form of address that younger brothers and sisters address their elder brother.  Katsuo is tall and strong like a real samurai.  

                美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
                在线情况
                8
                • 头像
                • 级别
                  • 积分3960
                  • 经验2571
                  • 文章14
                  • 注册2006-08-10
                  The story is the same (but I read two chapters only), but the writing styles are different. English version is straight to the point and the Chinese one is not as exciting as the Eng version.

                  Typo, it should be Karoi.

                  As a female reader, I am very eager to know how did Katsuo look like, I guess it is one of the reasons why Hitomi fell in love with her half-brother.He must/should be very handsome.


                  So far, I like Eng version more.

                  Thanks for your good work.



                  [img]../images/fileType/gif.gif[/img]此主题相关图片
                  [imga]../images/upload/2006/12/07/053440.gif[/imga]
                  請大家多多指教唷!
                  在线情况
                  9
                  • 头像
                  • 级别
                    • 职务总版主
                    • 财富7
                    • 积分689005
                    • 经验148181
                    • 文章9466
                    • 注册2005-07-12
                    I have never learned translation officially.  So, my translation is very amateurish. You are right to say that the English version is more natural as they come straight from my head.
                    I think Katsuo is good lookng but Hitomi loved him not only because of that.  There was no mention how he really looked like in the novel as I used first person to tell the story, which is difficult (Although not impossible) to describe one's appearance (I just do not like to do that anyway.  Readers can imagine.)

                    The English text needs careful proof reading before it can be considered for publishing.
                    美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
                    在线情况
                    10
                    • 头像
                    • 级别
                      • 职务总版主
                      • 财富7
                      • 积分689005
                      • 经验148181
                      • 文章9466
                      • 注册2005-07-12
                      Kaori was killed in the first battle.
                      I think it is also in the Chinese text.

                      The story gets much better after Chapter 5 of Book 1, all writers need a run-in time before the story can proceed naturally.

                      The chapters I like best are: chapter 8 of Book 2, chapter 4 of Book 3 and the final three chapters of Book 3 (not yet posted).  The Epilogue (not yet posted) is also quite good. and touching
                      美华文学论坛感谢您的参与
                      在线情况
                      11
                      • 头像
                      • 级别
                        • 积分3960
                        • 经验2571
                        • 文章14
                        • 注册2006-08-10
                        I didn't mean the translation is no good, conversely, I think you could master both Eng and Chinese very well.

                        The story of Ch and Eng is the same but the details are not.

                        The more description on the appearance, the more flesh and blood you give to the characters, I think.

                        Anyway, this is a very good attempt. Two thumbs up.
                         

                        [img]../images/fileType/gif.gif[/img]此主题相关图片
                        [imga]../images/upload/2006/12/08/052105.gif[/imga]
                        請大家多多指教唷!
                        在线情况
                        12
                        • 头像
                        • 级别
                          • 会员认证会员
                          • 财富1
                          • 积分48500
                          • 经验20000
                          • 文章77
                          • 注册2004-11-29
                          小土豆,你真了不起!
                          baolin cheng
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          loading...
                          回复帖子 注意: *为必填项
                          *验证信息 用户名 密码 注册新用户
                          *帖子名称
                          内容(最大25K)




                          其它选项 Alt+S快速提交
                           


                          Powered by LeadBBS 9.2 .
                          Page created in 0.1875 seconds with 5 queries.